Liven app
10,000+ 5 star reviews

Try the app!
List my business

Nicks Pizza

Claim this listing

Pizza restaurant

Otisville, New York

4.4
Claim this listing
About Nicks Pizza

Pizza restaurant

What people love
Pizza restaurant
Reviews
Steve Novak Apr 28, 2022
Amending my old review from Great to Good. The Pies definitely vary by who makes them. The first time and the next few times I ordered Nick was there, and the pies were awesome, 5-star, worth the extra driving. These past few times Nick was not there and the pies were just fair, and no longer worth going out-of-the-way for. They used to also have awesome Cannoli but no cannoli these days. But they do still have Fresh Mushrooms available, so that's an extra star right there! See less
... See all
Michael Petitti Apr 20, 2022
Nick's has really good food..been going there for a couple of years and never had a bad meal. See less
... See all
David Wallace Mar 07, 2022
Soup was super tasty. Good meatballs. Good place to heat. See less
... See all
Dante Pierson Dec 11, 2021
Ive known Nick and fam for 30 years. I was a very regular customer until i moved away. I went back for dinner and it brought me right back. Amazing food. See less
... See all
Mr Lugo Dec 03, 2021
I was just really hungry on my way to my friend's house. I see this place and think thank you, because I love pizza. I got a tomato basil slice and it was so delicious flavorful and juicy. I wish I had time for another. Definitely need to stop by again to try more See less
... See all
Scott Spratt Oct 09, 2021
Called to order a pie with banana peppers, didn't have them, asked for black olives and were out. Ordered pie anyway and was told 30 minutes, I was only 10 minutes away and was unable call back to to cancel because of spotty cell service. Thankfully, because the pizza was one of the best I've had in area and was done in 20 minutes and my wait wasn't bad at all. I'll be back!! See less
... See all
hexa phone Aug 31, 2021
I had chicken la francisco with angel hair pasta and a salad with house dressing. The meal was out standìngly delicious and very filling. I was well stuffed when I left. This is the best true Italian food you can get up here in New York out side of the little Italy in the City. Highly recommend it to everyone, a hidden jewel in the country. See less
... See all
Scott Aug 26, 2021
When Nick is doing the cooking all is excellent. Beyond that the food is mediocre. The chicken Marsalis has been very tough, the pizza is fair, sometimes pillow pie. Their idea of a thin crust needs attention, Their thin crust is the same as other pizzerias regular pie. perhaps a better micrometer. See less
... See all
Eric Basile Jun 01, 2021
Solid pizzeria! The man and woman working were friendly and helpful and the pizza was great! I purchased a Buffalo chicken pie which was loaded with chicken and super tasty! See less
... See all
Linda Kapetan Apr 15, 2021
Best white pizza hands down tons of pillow like Ricotta, I think it was home made. Real basil and tomatoes. The crust perfect crispy, not thick or gummy. It will be my next obsession. Don't pass thru otisville without stopping See less
... See all
Kelly Lee Feb 11, 2021
Best pizza I ever had, and you would say the same if you went there. Great quality ,perfect price to go with great quality food. I love it there! See less
... See all
Jodie Vandemark Nov 10, 2020
This was our first time eating at Nick's and we were pleasantly surprised. My husband loved the Sicilian pie and their Buffalo wings were delicious 😋. We will be back. See less
... See all
James Gardner Nov 04, 2020
After living here for 7 years I finally tried nicks pizza. We ordered chicken parm pizza, a Stromboli and spaghetti and meatballs. The food was surprisingly good. Never eating there before and having no expectations, I was pleasantly surprised. The food was fresh and tasty. I’m pretty tough on most places because I’m a jersey guy originally and Hoboken is my go to pizza town. The restaurant was clean and the staff seemed friendly enough. Their were a couple guys making pizza and they smiled and said hi when I walked in. A younger lady quickly asked if I needed help, and the prices are very reasonable. The only complaint I have is the lady that took my order over the phone was rude and treated me like I was inconveniencing her by calling in my order. I will definitely support this local business again. See less
... See all
Rachel S May 21, 2020
Our go to pizza place, always good generous amount of toppings delicious sauce and perfect crisp yet fluffy crust. It's May 2020 and I need to update my review, they have gone above and beyond during lock down and it's amazing. The staff is always busy but always kind and helpful. I also have to say I think they tweaked something in their pizza recipe because it has been tasting even better lately. Some new herbs or something cause wow it definitely has a boosted flavor. See less
... See all
Teresa Baudendistel Jan 26, 2020
Called over the phone to order a personal pan pie, they said they don’t do personal pies. Went there to pickup other food and when we walk in the guy that makes the pizza said “personal pan pepperoni”! Meanwhile the lady said they don’t make personal pies. Then was told it would be a 30 minute wait for my food and ended up waiting 45 minutes. 10 out of 10 would NOT recommend. Definitely never going back there that’s for sure! See less
... See all
+ 10 reviews
+ 10 reviews
FAQs
Does Nicks Pizza offer takeaway?

Yes, Nicks Pizza offers takeaway services. However we encourage you to call us first.

Where is Nicks Pizza located?

Its located at 61 State St, Otisville, NY 10963

About Nicks Pizza

Pizza restaurant

Contact Details

61 State St, Otisville, NY 10963
(845) 386-2222 phone3
Opening Days
Nicks Pizza is open 6 days a week ( Tuesday to Sunday) and closed on Monday. Please contact the business for actual opening hours.
Do you own Nicks Pizza?
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible

Buy now. Eat more.

For the savvy savers. Pre-purchase foodollars and score up to 100% bonus food credit instantly.

No expiry. No food envy. Liven Guarantee.

Download Liven today

Scan the code with your phone and get the app today!