Liven app
10,000+ 5 star reviews

Try the app!
List my business
List my business
Home > United States > New York > Otisville > Pizza > Pizza Mania

Pizza Mania

Claim this listing

Pizza restaurant

Otisville, New York

3.4
15 reviews
Claim this listing
About Pizza Mania

Pizza restaurant

What people love
Pizza restaurant
Features
Reviews
Yoleydis Matthews Apr 08, 2022
The staff is absolutely amazing and so friendly. I will definitely will be back. The pizza was awesome 👌. See less
... See all
Raz Mcdade Nov 06, 2021
Reall cool guys there...the customer service is what got the 5 stars...will be back 4 sure Truck drivers take these things serious See less
... See all
Jackie Talmadge Oct 28, 2021
Great Pizza ! Friday Nights were Pizza Mania Pizza usually! Sausage & Mushroom & Peppers for my Sister & Myself! Brian & Cindy the nicest people! I moved to AZ & really missed Pizza Mania Fridays w my sister & occasionally friends would join…. Hard to find NY Pizza in AZ but there are a few NY transplants! Mostly from Brooklyn & found a pizzeria owner from Kingston,NY but always raved about Brian’s Pizza Mania pizza 🍕 Gone for 2 1/2 yrs Came back for a visit & finally got my Pizza Mania Fix…… DELICIOUS 😋 MAYBE ONE MORE VISIT BEFORE HEADING BACK TO AZ! That would be AWESOME 👏 See less
... See all
Jennifer Vargas Mar 02, 2021
OMG delicious and great prices !! New to the area and found this little gem. Delicious pizza done to perfection and quick service. Highly recommend even for the picky little eaters! See less
... See all
Alayna F Nov 21, 2020
Horrible experience! When I entered to pick up my pizza neither the owner nor the other women behind the counter was wearing a proper mask and had their faces mostly uncovered. Then an apparent friend of theirs walked in and also did not have a mask on. when I asked why they don't require customers to wear a mask the owner said " It doesn't matter to me, i don't believe in the masks". My pizza was also dry and the broccoli was burnt. Nick's pizza in Ottisville is far better anyways! See less
... See all
Lisa Perkowski Oct 20, 2020
New location, same great food. The best scilian pie in Orange County! See less
... See all
Christian J Sep 19, 2020
Nice little SCAM they have going on here. 1st: In-store you can only pay cash. They have a surcharge ATM on premises if you would like to purchase anything. 2nd: If you order over the phone, you can pay credit card. *So if I walk down the street and pay by credit card over the phone, I don't have to bother withdrawing money from the bank. 3rd: There is a DELIVERY FEE (which was $3.00, last I knew). That delivery fee goes directly to the driver, so if you decide to leave gratuity, you left a tip, twice. Very, very shady business going on here. The food is not impressive by any means. There is another pizzeria not far from here that, in my opinion, has better food. Forget this place! See less
... See all
Marymbw Jun 11, 2020
We went to pick up our pizza last night. None of the employees were wearing masks. There weren't any signs posted stating that you must wear a mask when entering. None of the people waiting inside for food had masks on except for my husband. We have been eating from this restaurant for years. But we will never eat here again. See less
... See all
matthew eugenio Jan 15, 2020
I ordered from here about 3 weeks ago. The pizza was undercooked and loaded with too much cheese. My friend adon called it "un eatable" because of the quantity of cheese. However, i would like to compliment the delivery service! Very polite young man named zachary was a great deliverer! See less
... See all
Mortimer Marshall Jan 11, 2020
I had this rather “big boned” person delivering my pizza last week. Best pizza delivery man ever. I think is name is Zachary, I don’t know if he was lying about his name cuz he didn’t look like a Zachary. See less
... See all
Stevie G Jan 10, 2020
I had a great experience with the delivery service at Pizza Mania! I think the delivery boy was named Zack. He is the best delivery man I have ever sealed with! Give him a raise See less
... See all
Dakota Cortez Jan 10, 2020
We enjoy to go out. Last night we arrived in this superb place which we didn’t know before. We had a delightful experience there with superb meal and a nice stuff and a professional chief cook. We put this fine restaurant in our list and we shall no doubt visit again soon. We deeply recommend. See less
... See all
Sean McGinley Oct 12, 2019
italian combo and wings. Cost 22$. wings are dry and overcooked. To expensive. Italian combo looks like a toddler made it. Meat is not edible, I threw it away which i never do that with food. Its a nice looking place but they need to step up their food quality. See less
... See all
Marc Dusenbery Oct 12, 2019
Myself and a coworker were doing work in the area so we decided to grab lunch here. Boneless wings, fries, cup of soup. Over-charged from what the menu listed, waited 30 minutes for food and everything was absolutely horrible. How do you mess French fries up?? I could have blown the quality away with my air fryer at home. Horrible food!!! See less
... See all
Priestly Canty Jun 22, 2018
Excellent Grilled Chicken, & Crispy Chicken salad; Seasoned well. See less
... See all
+ 10 reviews
+ 10 reviews
FAQs
Does Pizza Mania offer takeaway?

Yes, Pizza Mania offers takeaway services. However we encourage you to call us first.

Where is Pizza Mania located?

Its located at 9 Main St, Otisville, NY 10963

About Pizza Mania

Pizza restaurant

Contact Details

9 Main St, Otisville, NY 10963
(845) 386-1010 phone4
Opening Days
Pizza Mania is open 6 days a week ( Monday to Saturday) and closed on Sunday. Please contact the business for actual opening hours.
Do you own Pizza Mania?
Tell us more about you and we will contact you as soon as possible
Similar restaurants
Here are some similar venues
Nicks Pizza
Pizza restaurant, Casual, Comfort foo...
Otisville, New York
4.4
Call venue
Directions
Claim page

Buy now. Eat more.

For the savvy savers. Pre-purchase foodollars and score up to 100% bonus food credit instantly.

No expiry. No food envy. Liven Guarantee.

Try it Out

Download Liven today

Scan the code with your phone and get the app today!